NYC- Stalled: Why Schools Are Restricting Bathroom Access

Cutting class. Fights. Vaping. School bathrooms have long been notorious for all sorts of illicit behavior. And in response, many schools now significantly restrict access to bathrooms or are adding surveillance tools, including vape detectors. 

Producers Isabella Mason, of Midwood High School, and Bernie Carmona, from Beacon High School, wade into the debate over school bathroom policies.

At Midwood, for instance, the school locks bathroom doors for the five minutes while changing classes, and bars access during the first and last 10 minutes of class. The school’s assistant principal of safety and security, Richard Franzese, discusses the evolution of the policy and the lengths the school has gone to crack down on incidents. Beyond limiting the times the bathrooms are open, the school has bathroom sign-in sheets, allowing up to three students in at a time, and has school aides stationed outside.

“There's no perfect solution,” he said. 

And Chalkbeat reporter Michael Elsen-Rooney sheds light on how schools are specifically responding to student vaping, illuminating the tension between simply enforcing rules versus dealing with larger issues related to addiction and mental health. 

https://www.bellvoices.org/ps-weekly-1/2025/5/14/stalled-why-schools-are-restricting-bathroom-access?ss_source=sscampaigns&ss_campaign_id=6825e6629f895311c5ea4089&ss_email_id=6825fabeb3ccf0609bc85589&ss_campaign_name=Stalled%3A+Why+schools+are+restricting+bathroom+access&ss_campaign_sent_date=2025-05-15T14%3A32%3A40Z