Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts

Friday, January 9, 2026

‘Over my dead body’: MoCo school board meeting gets tense over Wootton High closure proposal

The public comment portion of the Montgomery County Board of Education meeting Thursday was dominated by parents who oppose the proposal to close Wootton High School and send those students to the future Crown High School instead.

It’s just one element of the school district’s redistricting plan that would draw new boundaries in the state’s largest school district.

Throughout the meeting, parents held up signs and many wore tee shirts emblazoned with a large “W” featuring stars and stripes...

https://wtop.com/montgomery-county/2026/01/wooton-high-school-community-packs-mcps-board-meeting-on-closure-proposal/

Friday, May 24, 2024

Montgomery County substitute teacher sues over denied religious...

 https://thedailyrecord.com/2024/05/22/montgomery-county-substitute-teacher-sues-over-denied-religious-accommodations-on-gender-identity-policy/

~~~~~~~and~~~~~~~~~~~

A Montgomery County Public Schools substitute teacher says in a federal lawsuit that she was required to assist students as young as three years old to transition genders at school, in violation of her Christian faith.

The Maryland school district’s gender identity guidelines also require employees to withhold from unsupportive parents when their child is transitioning genders, unless the child consents, according to the suit filed Tuesday. The guidelines apply to students of all ages and a related form requires minors “exhibiting transgender inclinations or actions to identify a ‘Support Level’ they believe would be provided by their parents,” the ...

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/christian-teacher-in-maryland-sues-over-gender-transition-policy



Tuesday, November 21, 2023

Former Gaithersburg High School wrestler awarded $4 million in damages in sexual assault case


...Montgomery Parents Coalition leader Janis Zink Sartucci told FOX 5 that, once again, Montgomery County school officials refuse to speak out on the case.

"We have one very clear pattern here in Montgomery County, and that clear pattern is of the adults in charge hiding," he said. "We don’t see them speaking about these cases. We don’t see them standing up for victims. We don’t see them supporting the victims in any way, shape or form."

FOX 5 reached out to Montgomery County Public Schools and received no reply...

 Former Gaithersburg High School wrestler awarded $4 million in damages in sexual assault case (fox5dc.com)

Wednesday, June 14, 2023

Breaking: Montgomery County Public Schools Join Federal Lawsuit Against Social Media Companies

SAN DIEGOJune 14, 2023 /PRNewswire/ -- Frantz Law Group announces that the Montgomery County Public School District joined 500 school districts nationwide in a lawsuit filed in Federal District Court in San Francisco against Meta, TikTok, Snap, YouTube, and other social media companies. In the lawsuit the plaintiff school districts allege that these companies are knowingly causing emotional harm to children through their platforms.

With over 160,550 students in 210 schools, the Montgomery County Public School District is the largest school district in the state of Maryland. The lawsuit alleges that various social media companies have caused a mental and emotional health crisis marked by higher proportions of anxiety, depression, thoughts of self-harm, body dissatisfaction, disordered eating behaviors, and low self-esteem among children and students. Many are further subjected to often harmful, exploitative and addictive content that encourages disorderly behavior, unhealthy social comparison, and cyberbullying. This litigation seeks to provide the funding and staffing resources needed to mitigate the damage that school districts are currently encountering.

In May of this year, U.S. Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy issued a new Advisory on Social Media and Youth Mental Health, in which he states, "…there is growing evidence that social media use is associated with harm to young people's mental health." The Advisory cites research finding that one-third or more of girls aged 11-15 say they feel "addicted" to certain social media platforms, that 46% of adolescents aged 13-17 said social media makes them feel worse, and that 64% of adolescents are "often" or "sometimes" exposed to hate-based content through social media. The Advisory also points to studies that show "a relationship between social media use and poor sleep quality, reduced sleep duration, sleep difficulties, and depression among youth."

Moreover, in October 2021, former Meta employee Frances Haugen testified before Congress that Meta's own internal research indicated how harmful their products are to the mental health of child users and, in particular, teenage girls.

Montgomery County Public Schools Join Federal Lawsuit Against Social Media Companies (prnewswire.com)

Thursday, December 1, 2022

[@mocoboe Ignores Another Victim, Gets Sued Again.] Family of student shot at Magruder sues county, school board

The family of a Magruder High School student shot inside a school bathroom has filed a lawsuit against Montgomery County and its school board, alleging the county created danger and the school system neglected its duty of care by stopping the school resource officer program, which removed police from schools...

...A complaint, which lists Thomas’s mother, Karen Thomas, as the plaintiff and was filed in Montgomery County Circuit Court, alleges that the county deprived Thomas “of his right to a reasonably safe and secure public education” and that the school system did not take any action to curb rising reports of violence on school grounds after students returned to campuses after remote learning during the beginning of the pandemic...

Family of student shot at Magruder sues county, school board (msn.com)

Monday, May 16, 2022

Anne Arundel Co. reaches $2.5M settlement with family of teen who died after eating glove

The parents of an autistic 17-year-old who choked on a glove at school have reached a $2.5 million dollar settlement with the school system in Anne Arundel County, Maryland.

Bowen Levy’s parents filed a federal suit against the school system last year, saying its negligence is responsible for their son’s November 2019 death. The family said Bowen had a compulsive condition that caused him to swallow and eat nonfood items.

“Bowen’s death has had an enormous impact on many, but nowhere has that impact been more massive than on his beloved family. We recognize that nothing that occurs from here forward will ever fill the void in their lives,” AACPS said in a statement...

https://wtop.com/anne-arundel-county/2022/05/anne-arundel-co-reaches-2-5m-settlement-with-family-of-teen-who-died-after-eating-glove/?fbclid=IwAR1UWJMDvUeLuGmnHdciG3U6glekqHodrdlbOubbtsWOLB-sYhxh2IfzVpg

Thursday, April 7, 2022

Family of teen hit by Jeep while catching school bus sues Montgomery County Public Schools

ROCKVILLE, Md. (7News) — The family of a former Walter Johnson High School student has filed a lawsuit against Montgomery County Public Schools, Montgomery County Government, and two others involved in a crash that left the teen "catastrophically injured."

The civil lawsuit was filed on March 14, in Montgomery County Circuit Court. It requests a six-person jury trial to span an estimated six days in pursuit of a judgment in excess of $75,000...

https://wjla.com/news/local/eyal-haddad-walter-johnson-high-school-student-hit-car-school-bus-montrose-road-2019-montgomery-county-public-schools-civil-lawsuit-filed

Thursday, November 4, 2021

Breaking: 3 Year Old Plastic Football Field at Whitman High School Out of Commission for Playoff Games. Report [Pictures] Documented 27 Repairs in October.

Dear Walt Whitman High School Community Members,

The purpose of this email is to update the community on the state of our turf field and it’s use for sports and activities. The field has been used throughout the fall by multiple Whitman teams and outside organizations like MSI soccer. During the fall season, we have collaborated with MCPS in monitoring its condition. Subsequently, the field has undergone repairs and been assessed multiple times by MCPS facilities specialists to ensure the safety of our students and outside users. 

Out of an abundance of caution, we will not be using the field for the remainder of the fall sports season, specifically two home playoff games for girls soccer and field hockey respectively. Both of these games will be played at Walter Johnson High School on the evening of Friday, November 4. Whitman field hockey will play Urbana High School at 6:00pm and Whitman girls soccer will play Parkdale High School at 8:00pm. 

With the fall regular sports season concluded, we will collaborate with MCPS to further evaluate the playing surface of the field in order to identify any necessary repairs that need to be made in the months ahead. We will keep our community updated on any actions that are taken.  

While we are disappointed that we are unable to use the field for these two important games, we are nonetheless proud of all that our student athletes accomplished during the fall sports season at Whitman. As always, our students and parents are encouraged to attend these playoff games at Walter Johnson High School to support our field hockey and girls soccer teams. 

Sincerely,

Robert W. Dodd, EdD

Principal

Walt Whitman High School

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Image above shows Picture #27 of seam tears in Whitman High School/MSI artificial turf football/soccer field from October 19, 2021 Maintenance Report below: 


Walt Whitman High School - ... by Parents' Coalition of Montg...

Monday, February 1, 2021

MCPS files to dismiss magnet admissions lawsuit

...In March 2019, the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights opened an investigation into allegations similar to the ones raised the lawsuit. The Washington Post reported at the time that federal officials received 10 complaints raising concerns about the magnet program. The Office of Civil Rights website lists the investigation as still open. A spokesperson declined to comment last week.

Tuesday, November 10, 2020

Nashville reaches tentative harassment settlement of $1.2M with former public school administrator (Also Former MCPS Administrator - Moreno Carrasco)


NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WTVF) — Lawyers for Metro Nashville Public Schools have reached a proposed settlement of a $1.2 million sexual harassment lawsuit filed by a former district administrator.

Terms of the final settlement with Dr. Vanessa Garcia have not been made public. That deal still must be approved by the Metro School Board, according to Metro deputy law director Mike Safley.

Latest case to be settled from Shawn Joseph tenure

items.[0].image.alt

Copyright 2018 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

By: Phil WilliamsPosted at 3:53 PM, Jan 06, 2020 and last updated 5:12 PM, Jan 06, 2020

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WTVF) — Lawyers for Metro Nashville Public Schools have reached a proposed settlement of a $1.2 million sexual harassment lawsuit filed by a former district administrator.


Terms of the final settlement with Dr. Vanessa Garcia have not been made public. That deal still must be approved by the Metro School Board, according to Metro deputy law director Mike Safley.

The proposed settlement, disclosed in a new court filing Monday, came less than three weeks after U.S. District Judge William L. Campbell Jr. rejected numerous efforts by the school district's lawyers to throw out various claims made by Garcia.

Garcia's lawsuit accuses former Metro Schools administrator Mo Carrasco of grossly inappropriate sexual comments, as well as one occasion when he allegedly put his hand on her breast at a district Christmas party.

After Garcia filed a formal complaint back in November 2017, other witnesses came forward - and Carrasco resigned. In May 2018, Garcia herself lost her job as part of a so-called "realignment."...

https://www.newschannel5.com/news/newschannel-5-investigates/metro-schools/mnps-reaches-tentative-harassment-settlement-with-former-administrator

Thursday, February 6, 2020

Press Release: LAWSUITS FILED ON BEHALF OF MINOR STUDENTS SEXUALLY ASSAULTED IN DAMASCUS FOOTBALL LOCKERROOM

LAWSUITS FILED ON BEHALF OF MINOR STUDENTS SEXUALLY ASSAULTED
IN DAMASCUS FOOTBALL LOCKERROOM

         Today, law firms representing four minors who were victims of vicious sexual assaults occurring in the unsupervised football locker room at Damascus High School in 2017 and 2018 filed suit on their clients’ behalves. The lawsuits name as defendants the Montgomery County Board of Education, former Principal Casey Crouse, former football coaches Vincent Colbert and Eric Wallich, and former Athletic Director Joseph Doody.

            Billy Murphy, Founding Partner at Murphy, Falcon & Murphy, said today, “Winning football games was more important than the safety and protection of these young boys. The Board of Education and Damascus administrators and coaches fumbled their handling of these incidents in order to protect the brand and protect the football team’s winning streak.”

The lawsuits allege that coaches, teachers, and administrators knew about the Damascus High School tradition called “brooming” wherein sophomore football players terrorized freshmen football players by threatening to, and at times, forcibly sodomizing the younger players with a broom. The lawsuits allege that despite notification from parents and concerned adults, officials at Damascus permitted the longstanding ritual to continue.

Tom DeGonia, a Partner at Ethridge Quinn added, “Instead of notifying victims’ parents and law enforcement as required, the administrators took it upon themselves to investigate and interrogate the victims. Critical time was lost by their actions.”

The lawsuits further allege that Defendants failed to supervise the locker room after school and before football practice, failed to protect the victims from attack, and failed to timely notify parents and law enforcement of the sexual assaults after they occurred. The lawsuits further allege that Defendants knew about locker room sexual assaults at Damascus and other high schools in Montgomery County prior to the widely publicized October 31, 2018 event but were wholly indifferent to them. The lawsuits further allege Defendants knew about the violent propensities of one of the attackers, but nonetheless permitted that student to enroll at Damascus in order to further the football team’s national prominence.

Tim Maloney, a Partner at Joseph, Greenwald & Laake, P.A. continued, “The failures by those tasked with protecting these boys are evident. It would be a miscarriage of justice should the responsible administrators and coaches not be held accountable for their actions.”

Anyone with information as to these and other locker room assaults are urged to call 1-800-277-0150 and report their information.



About Murphy, Falcon & Murphy, P.A.
Murphy, Falcon & Murphy, P.A. is a Baltimore-based law firm that specializes in complex litigation. Our powerhouse team has a history of unrelenting dedication to its clients, and our team of seasoned trial lawyers has extensive experience in a variety of cases with success rates that dwarf national averages. We are dedicated to providing smart strategies and creative approaches to complex litigation. Our team is driven and strategy-focused— characteristics that have helped us secure over $700 million for our clients. Learn more at www.murphyfalcon.com.

About Ethridge, Quinn, Kemp, Rowan & Hartinger
Ethridge Quinn is a litigation powerhouse in Maryland and Washington D.C.  We have a reputation as one of the most knowledgeable and successful firms in the state. We walk to court every day, and our courtroom experience draws a wide variety of clients, individuals, small and medium-sized businesses, and large national corporations, searching for distinguished representation. Our attorneys maintain successful litigation and business law practices in areas such as business litigation, family law, personal injury, criminal law, wrongful death, government investigations, appellate law, estates and trusts, and civil litigation. www.eqlawyers.com

About Joseph, Greenwald & Laake, P.A.
Joseph, Greenwald & Laake, PA is a law firm with offices in Greenbelt and Rockville, Maryland. For more than 50 years, Joseph Greenwald and Laake has been one of Maryland’s leading trial law firms.  Its lawyers have done groundbreaking work in civil litigation, civil rights, constitutional law and business and family law litigation. www.jgllaw.com/.



Wednesday, August 1, 2018

Lawsuit Over Gaithersburg Teen’s Death in Gym Class Continues in County Court

...The mother of Taylor Walton, a 14-year-old Gaithersburg High School student, filed the lawsuit after Taylor’s death in 2015 after an asthma attack in gym class.
The complaint claims that Taylor started having trouble breathing during her gym class on Nov. 30, 2015, and asked permission to get her inhaler out of her locker. Her gym teacher wouldn’t let her leave class after two requests.
Taylor later left the class without permission and was found unconscious near the gymnasium a short time later, according to court filings.
The federal complaint claimed that two Gaithersburg High School teachers were grossly negligent in refusing Taylor’s requests to leave class to get an inhaler and violated her civil rights by denying her permission to leave, and that the Board of Education was negligent in hiring and supervising employees...


Lawsuit Over Gaithersburg Teen’s Death in Gym Class Continues in County Court: A federal judge denied claim of Fourth Amendment violation, but made no decision on negligence claims

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Court reinstates verdict against Board of Education. Bd of Ed Breached Duty of Care in Placement of Bus Stop

ANNAPOLIS — A Maryland appeals court has reinstated a jury’s verdict — but not its $90.3 million damages award — for the parents of a 13-year-old girl who was struck and killed by a car six years ago while crossing a four-lane street trying to reach her school-bus stop in Temple Hills.
The Court of Special Appeals said the trial judge was wrong to toss out the jury’s verdict against the Prince George’s County Board of Education based on his erroneous finding that it owed no duty of care to the girl and that her negligent crossing of the street contributed to her death. In its 3-0 decision, the intermediate court said the board owed a duty to the girl under a regulation governing bus-stop locations and that a jury reasonably concluded she was not contributorily negligent.
“It was a very important ruling by the court,” said the family’s attorney, John F. X. Costello. “Because that regulation was not complied with, this little girl was forced to cross the street.”
The Court of Special Appeals, however, said state law calls for the award to be reduced to the school board’s insurance policy limit, but not to less than $100,000. The board has the defense of sovereign immunity from damages for amounts greater, the court said in remanding the case to Prince George’s County Circuit Court to determine the award...

 “Many of these governmental caps have not been adjusted in [many] years and are drawing the attention of the General Assembly,” said Maloney, of Joseph, Greenwald & Laake P.A. in Greenbelt.

...The Prince George’s County Circuit Court jury had found in April 2013 that the school board fatally breached its duty of care to Ashley Davis by not providing a school-bus stop on the same side of Brinkley Road as her home, thus requiring the freshman at Crossland High School in Temple Hills to cross the four-lane thoroughfare.
Ashley was killed while crossing Brinkley Road on Sept. 1, 2009. The driver admitted no liability in reaching a $20,000 settlement with the family.
The jury, in finding the school board liable, concluded that Ashely was not contributorily negligent...

...But the Court of Special Appeals reinstated the verdict, citing Maryland State Board of Education regulation 13A.06.07.13, which pertains to “Reporting and Operating Procedures.” Subsection C of the regulation states that “on four-lane highways, students shall be picked up and discharged on the side of the roadway where they reside.”
Subsection C is “designed to protect public-school students who ride county-provided buses to and from school from the risks associated with crossing a four-lane highway, including the risk of being hit by a car,” Judge Deborah S. Eyler wrote in the appellate court’s reported opinion filed Friday.
“As a public-school student living on a four-lane highway, in a school district in which the board had taken it upon itself to provide bus transportation to school, Ashley was within the specific class of people that [Subsection C] was designed to protect,” Eyler added. “And she suffered precisely the kind of injury that the regulation was intended to protect against. Accordingly, the board owed Ashley a legal duty of care to provide a bus stop on her side of Brinkley Road sufficient to support the duty element of a cause of action in negligence.”...

 ... Section 4-105 of the Maryland Education Article requires county school boards to have at least $100,000 in liability coverage. Section 5-518 of the Maryland Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article, titled “Immunity – County boards of education” provides that the boards “may raise the defense of sovereign immunity to any amount claimed above the limit of its insurance policy….”
 http://thedailyrecord.com/2015/04/06/court-reinstates-verdict-sans-90m-award-in-teens-death/?utm_source=WhatCounts+Publicaster+Edition&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=TDR+Insider+4%2f7%2f15&utm_content=Court+reinstates+verdict%2c+sans+%2490M+award%2c+in+teen%27s+death

Friday, January 31, 2014

Charles County BOE discloses settlement amount

The Charles County Board of Education paid $225,000 in settlement of a former office assistant’s claim that the board transferred, demoted and left her no choice but to quit after she complained of being groped and sexually harassed by her boss.
The settlement with Stephanie Rosa was reported Dec. 17 but the school system declined to disclose the amount at the time. The Daily Record filed a request for the amount under the Maryland Public Information Act, citing the use of public funds, and counsel for the school system responded by email dated Jan. 17.
The school board admitted no wrongdoing in agreeing to the settlement, which also covers Rosa’s claims against her former boss, Patrick A. Tague. Rosa agreed to be ineligible for future employment with the board under the settlement.
 http://thedailyrecord.com/2014/01/23/charles-county-discloses-settlement-amount/

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Does Starr Really Support Fighting Parents of Disabled Children?

Twitter screen showing that Superintendent Starr retweeted
a tweet from @nawlins.  Starr's picture is on far right side
at bottom of screen shot.
Twitter seems to be one way to find out what Superintendent Joshua Starr ("Josh") likes and doesn't like.

Yesterday, I saw that Josh (aka @mcpssuper) had re-tweeted a quote from one of the current Board of Education candidates, Jeanne Ellinport (aka @nawlins)

The quote? "What you permit is what you promote."

So, since Josh arrived at MCPS last July, what has he permitted? And by extension, what is he "promoting?"

Well, it seems that Josh is promoting the "scorched earth" litigation policy begun by his predecessor, Jerry Weast. This unwritten policy from the central office at 850 Hungerford Drive is to fight parents of children with disabilities when the parents request more or different services for their child.

Let's look at how much money MCPS has spent on special education litigation since Josh arrived in town. This money doesn't include the so-called office of Equity Assurance, or the existing Legal Services unit (which just hired a new lawyer, by the way). No, the money reflected in the MCPS legal fees report only represents money spent on outside counsel. (Wonder if Josh has asked why we need to spend money on high priced outside counsel when we already have in-house lawyers...but that's a post for another day.)

November 8, 2011 BOE meeting:
Special education legal fees for outside counsel for August 2011 totaled $9,994
The year-to-date total of $57,398 is $10,459 (15 percent) lower than the same period in the previous fiscal year.
The Jeffrey A. Krew bill for August 2011 totaled $7,180. The bill included work on five cases, two
of which involved administrative hearings ($2,947), two of which involved an appeal to federal court
($3,233), and one of which involved an Individualized Education Program ($1,000).
The Carney Kelehan bill for August 2011 totaled $2,814 and involved work on two Individualized
Education Programs


December 6, 2011 BOE meeting:
Special education outside counsel bill for September 2011 was $20,581 = four cases.


January 10, 2012 BOE meeting:
Special Education Legal Expenses
Special education legal fees for outside counsel for October 2011 totaled $75,533. The year-to-date total of $153,512 is $8,162 (6 percent) higher than the same period in the previous fiscal year.


The Jeffrey A. Krew bill for October 2011 totaled $73,563. The bill included work on nine cases, six of which involved administrative hearings ($71,239) and three of which involved an appeal to federal court ($2,057). In addition there were legal service fees of $267.
The Carney Kelehan bill for October 2011 totaled $1,970 and involved work on one Individualized Education Program.

So, Josh: what you permit is what you promote? Looks like you're promoting fighting families instead of working with them. And I'm not interested in a letter from one of your henchmen trying to explain this away. Let's hear exactly what you have to say about this, and why you think spending this kind of money is in children and taxpayers' interests, at the special ed forum coming up at Seneca Valley HS on Monday, April 16.

Thursday, January 26, 2012

Open Letter to Starr, County Council ED Committee

Dear Dr. Starr and Ms. Ervin:

At the County Council hearing on the OLO Autism report the other day, the conversation veered off into special education dispute resolution. Dr. Starr stated, repeating an earlier theme, that he doesn't want to hear anecdotes, but that he wants Data and Facts.

Unfortunately, the special education hearing decisions that are posted on the MSDE website are so heavily redacted (even school names are redacted) that it is impossible for advocates to know which schools and programs are even the subject of dispute.

Nevertheless, the current superintendent has responsiblity for the actions that have occurred since
he arrived on the scene in July. Dr. Starr's statement that there were "only" 120 dispute resolution requests last year doesn't include the 27 state complaints from FY 2011, which is the "poor man's" method of dispute resolution since MCPS embarked on its "scorched earth" special education dispute resolution
policy during the Weast years.

I look forward to the Council's upcoming discussion on special education dispute resolution. You may not realize that a budget review committee specifically looked at this issue many years ago, and found that MCPS utilized special education dispute resolution as a "cost containment" method. In addition, I will be happy to provide the Council with a copy of their "outside counsel" contract for special education legal services, which provides that outside counsel be paid $6,000 a day per day of litigation. Even in the Washington DC area, with its stable of high-priced lawyers, I do not know any other litigators that command $6,000 a day for working for a public, governmental entity.

Sincerely,

Lyda Astrove